THE DAY, IN CONTEXTPolaris InsightsAn AI-powered comprehensive news portal

POLARIS INSIGHTS

Erasmus challenges TMO decisions before South Africa’s Ireland Test

Erasmus challenges TMO decisions before South Africa’s Ireland Test

South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus has questioned whether officials’ failure to penalise alleged illegal tackles in the Springboks’ 21-19 defeat by France amounted to manipulation of the result, intensifying scrutiny before Saturday’s Test against Ireland in Dublin.

At a Monday press conference, Erasmus said France made 17 knee-drop or hip-drop tackles during the match in Paris that he believed should have been reviewed. He said 11 warranted at least a penalty and three could have merited yellow cards, but claimed neither the referee nor Television Match Official Matteo Liperini intervened. Erasmus also said South Africa had asked the referee during the match to examine suspected knee-drop tackles.

Erasmus said he was not accusing the officials of wrongdoing. He argued that if the TMO did not see the incidents, rugby’s technology needed improvement, while a decision to see them and ignore them could amount to influencing the outcome or exposing players to injury. He also criticised the broader preference for TMOs to avoid interrupting play, pointing to a lengthy review of a South African try and claiming France scrum-half Maxime Lucu served seven minutes rather than the full 10-minute yellow-card period.

Erasmus called the tackle serious and said he expected Prendergast to play against South Africa because of a possible technicality. He contrasted the case with disciplinary outcomes involving South African players, including Jan-Hendrik Wessels’ nine-week suspension, while noting that he was not a legal expert and was not claiming anyone had acted improperly.

World Rugby had not publicly responded to Erasmus’s comments. The governing body has previously sanctioned him for criticism of officials: he received a two-month suspension from rugby and a 10-month matchday ban after comments during the 2021 British and Irish Lions tour, then served a two-match suspension in 2022 after social-media criticism following defeats by Ireland and France. South Africa has also made five changes for the Ireland match, including the return of Eben Etzebeth, who is set to make his 148th Test appearance, while Cameron Hanekom replaces the suspended Jasper Wiese.

Read the full account of the story

More from the Sports desk

More from Sports · Back to Polaris Insights