THE DAY, IN CONTEXTPolaris InsightsAn AI-powered comprehensive news portal

POLARIS INSIGHTS

CFTC challenges Utah’s bid to regulate Kalshi prediction contracts under state gambling law

The state alleged that Kalshi’s event contracts amounted to illegal gambling and sought an order preventing the platform from offering contracts tied to sports, elections, politics, culture and other outcomes. Utah also asked for profits earned from customers in the state and for court-approved geolocation controls.

The federal complaint argues that the contracts targeted by Utah are swaps and that the exchanges offering them are designated contract markets regulated by the CFTC. It says federal law gives the commission exclusive authority over commodity futures, options and swaps traded on federally regulated exchanges, and that Utah’s enforcement effort conflicts with that federal framework. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said the commission was defending what he described as its sole responsibility for overseeing prediction markets. The agency said it had also opened proceedings against nine other states and filed briefs in several appellate and state courts.

The dispute follows a separate federal case Kalshi brought against Utah in February. District Judge Robert Shelby ruled that Utah’s anti-gambling laws could apply to sports-betting contracts offered by Kalshi and rejected the company’s argument that the Commodity Exchange Act displaced state enforcement. Circuit Court of Appeals later declined to pause Utah’s enforcement while Kalshi appealed, a decision that helped prompt the state’s civil action.

The conflict escalated again on Oct. 28, when Utah filed criminal charges against Kalshi and co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara. The charges included 13 alleged gambling-law violations and an allegation involving profits from illegal activity. Utah Attorney General Derek Brown said federal registration did not place Kalshi above state law, while Kalshi has maintained that it is a national derivatives exchange whose customers trade contracts under federal oversight. The federal lawsuit seeks declaratory and injunctive relief; the competing cases leave the central question—whether state gambling rules can govern these contracts—unresolved.

Read the full account of the story

More from the Crypto desk

More from Crypto · Back to Polaris Insights