THE DAY, IN CONTEXTPolaris InsightsAn AI-powered comprehensive news portal

POLARIS INSIGHTS

Manhattan Judge Ends $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case After Finding No Proven Deception

A Manhattan federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Nov. 16, ending the U.S. Government’s first criminal prosecution centered on a maximal extractable value, or MEV, exploit on Ethereum. Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke cleared the MIT-educated brothers of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The decision followed a 2025 mistrial after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict and directs the clerk to close the case.

The prosecution arose from an April 2023 operation in which the brothers targeted automated trading bots that scan Ethereum’s public transaction queue for opportunities. In a common “sandwich” strategy, a bot buys a token before another trader’s purchase and sells immediately afterward, seeking to profit from the resulting price movement. Prosecutors alleged that the brothers placed eight bait transactions to attract those bots, then used a vulnerability in relay software to obtain the bots’ pending trades before replacing the bait with transactions of their own.

The altered block allowed the bots’ purchases to go through while the brothers sold the same illiquid tokens into the trades. The bots lost approximately $25 million in about 12 seconds, while the brothers’ validator incurred a penalty of about 1 ether, valued at a few thousand dollars. The government’s original indictment described the operation as involving manipulated transaction ordering and alleged that the brothers used multiple cryptocurrency addresses, companies and exchanges to move the proceeds.

Clarke’s ruling turned on the legal requirements of wire fraud rather than on whether the strategy was ethical or consistent with the intended design of the relay system. Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation—a false statement or promise significant enough to influence the person or system allegedly deceived. The judge found that prosecutors had not shown the bait transactions promised the bots that the transactions would be executed in the way the bots expected, and that the falsified signature did not influence the relay because the relevant fields were not checked.

The judge wrote that Ethereum is a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use, ” while acknowledging that the brothers concealed their plans and may have frustrated the spirit of the software’s design. She also emphasized that conduct can be improper or objectionable without satisfying the elements of a federal fraud offense. Because the money-laundering conspiracy charge depended on proceeds from the alleged wire fraud, the acquittal resolved that count as well.

The case leaves a fact-specific ruling on the boundary between technical exploitation and criminal deception. It does not establish that every MEV strategy or software exploit is lawful, and it does not erase the underlying losses described by prosecutors. The immediate procedural result is final for this prosecution: the brothers have been acquitted, the mistrial will not lead to a second trial in this case, and the court has ordered the matter closed.

Read the full account of the story

More from the Crypto desk

More from Crypto · Back to Polaris Insights