A London High Court judge has ruled that Chinese law must govern claims to more than 61,000 Bitcoin seized from a fraud investigation, dealing a setback to victims seeking direct ownership of the cryptocurrency.
Justice Mark Turner rejected arguments that English law, or a combination of English and Chinese law, should apply. He said the alleged losses occurred in China, where investors paid money and entered the relevant contractual relationships. The ruling establishes the legal framework for the claims but does not decide who owns the Bitcoin or how it will be distributed.
The dispute concerns a scheme linked to Zhimin Qian that operated in China between 2014 and 2017. More than 128,000 investors were affected, and British authorities later recovered devices containing about 61,000 Bitcoin during a money-laundering investigation.
The victims had argued for English law because it could support proprietary claims to the Bitcoin itself, including any increase in value, rather than leaving them only as creditors seeking compensation. They also challenged a proposed arrangement involving a Chinese redress process, saying it could allow British authorities to retain much of the cryptocurrency’s appreciation.
The proceedings will remain in the High Court. The next stage is expected to examine expert evidence on Chinese law and whether individual claimants can establish property interests in the seized assets. Lawyers representing the claimants are pursuing an appeal, while the Crown Prosecution Service is expected to address how Chinese law applies and whether victims can prove an interest in the Bitcoin.
The scale of the case has grown as the cryptocurrency’s value rose. The court’s latest decision narrows the legal route available to those claimants but leaves the underlying ownership dispute unresolved.
