Coinbase and five other companies are defending the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s authority to allow perpetual futures tied to individual US stocks, placing a crypto-born derivatives structure at the center of a federal regulatory dispute. Arthur Hayes, the BitMEX co-founder associated with the product’s early development, said he was “flattered” that Coinbase is now defending a market structure that Washington viewed skeptically when BitMEX introduced Bitcoin perpetual swaps in 2016.
The Capital Markets Alliance Association, whose members include Cboe and Citadel Securities, filed suit seeking to overturn the CFTC’s treatment of the contracts. The alliance argues that stock perpetuals are security-based swaps rather than security futures, which would put them under the Securities and Exchange Commission’s jurisdiction and subject them to tighter restrictions affecting retail trading. The contracts provide leveraged exposure to a stock’s price without requiring ownership of the underlying shares and, unlike conventional futures, have no expiration date.
Coinbase, Kalshi, Kraken parent Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm filed a court brief supporting the CFTC. Coinbase, Kalshi and Bitnomial had submitted applications to list perpetual futures linked to individual large-cap US stocks, and those applications were deemed approved on Nov. 2 after the CFTC’s review period elapsed.
The companies argue that the SEC and CFTC jointly considered how perpetual contracts should be classified and that both agencies were involved in the listing framework. Their brief says the products are cash-settled, centrally cleared, traded on margin and comparable in key respects to security futures, with the lack of an expiration date presented as the principal difference. Coinbase’s legal position is commercially significant because the company has sought to expand derivatives beyond crypto and previously launched stock perpetuals for eligible traders outside the United States.
3, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the alliance’s request for a temporary restraining order, ruling that it had not shown likely irreparable harm. She nevertheless found that the alliance was likely to succeed on its argument that the CFTC lacked authority because contracts with no future delivery date may not meet the statutory definition of a security future and may instead qualify as swaps regulated by the SEC.
The SEC’s position remains unresolved. The agency opposed an immediate halt while reviewing the exchanges’ listing rules, but it did not settle whether the products are security futures or security-based swaps. Cboe separately urged the SEC to reject the listings, arguing that perpetual contracts lack final settlement or delivery and could create surveillance gaps because trading data might fall outside the securities market’s Consolidated Audit Trail.
A legal adviser cited in the case warned that a ruling against the CFTC could move activity to offshore or decentralized platforms rather than eliminate demand. For Hayes, the fight marks a reversal in the regulatory reception of perpetual swaps; for Coinbase and its allies, the outcome will determine whether that structure can become a US-listed equity product under joint federal oversight.
