The group’s early months were marked by disputes over how it should operate as an opposition. In September, Welsh Reform leader Dan Thomas resigned after being arrested and released on bail on suspicion of assault and coercive or controlling behaviour. Thomas said he had done nothing wrong and that he was stepping down to prevent the case from becoming a distraction; he remained a Member of the Senedd. Before his resignation, he had said Reform was prepared to take power during the four-year term and had criticised Plaid Cymru’s legislative programme and handling of spending plans.
The same day Thomas left the leadership, Sarah Cooper-Lesadd defected from Reform to Plaid Cymru. Cooper-Lesadd, elected for Pen-y-bont Bro Morgannwg in May and previously appointed Reform’s shadow minister for children, young people and skills, said she no longer believed her former party was serious about governing Wales. She also criticised what she described as an emphasis on division, opposition and headlines, and said she could not support attacks on people seeking sanctuary or other vulnerable groups. Plaid Cymru admitted that accepting a defector from Reform required careful consideration but approved her admission as its 44th Senedd member.
A six-month investigation into the Reform group reported that at least one Reform member was absent from 31 of 100 Senedd committee meetings held between May 8 and October 21. The comparable figures were eight meetings for Plaid Cymru, nine for Labour, nine for the Conservatives, six for the Greens and one for the Liberal Democrats. Committees are a central mechanism for examining Welsh Government policy and spending, so the attendance figures provide a measurable indication of how the enlarged opposition group has participated in scrutiny.
The investigation also reported claims from Senedd members and staffers that Reform maintained restrictions on contact with named charities and journalists, and that Nigel Farage’s approval was required before the Welsh group could work with another party. Reform rejected the claims as unsubstantiated. Further tensions emerged after Reform member Joe Martin made comments about the future share of white British people in the UK; the Senedd’s presiding officer said Martin would not be called to speak again until he apologised, prompting acting Welsh leader Helen Jenner to say the group would boycott the chamber in solidarity. Jenner was also reported to have suggested that Reform members attend and disrupt a cross-party group examining issues affecting women in parliament and wider society. The immediate consequence is a party with substantial representation but reduced numbers after the defection, a new leadership structure and continuing questions over whether it can convert electoral support into sustained parliamentary scrutiny.
