THE DAY, IN CONTEXTPolaris InsightsAn AI-powered comprehensive news portal

POLARIS INSIGHTS

FOI records expose ACMA’s reversal of staff findings on ABC War Memorial investigation

FOI records expose ACMA’s reversal of staff findings on ABC War Memorial investigation

Freedom-of-information records show that Australian Communications and Media Authority staff initially concluded the ABC’s Four Corners investigation into the Australian War Memorial did not breach the broadcaster’s impartiality code, before the Authority adopted the opposite finding.

The episode, titled “Sacrifice, ” aired on 10 March 2025 and examined the memorial’s redevelopment, including contract management, consultation processes and findings from an Australian National Audit Office review. The Australian War Memorial first complained to the ABC, but the broadcaster’s ombudsman found no editorial breach. Memorial council chair Kim Beazley then referred the matter to ACMA.

Internal notes released through FOI included an assessment that the concerns were probably not serious enough to constitute a breach. Another note said the balance of the evidence indicated no breach, although the ABC could have made some points clearer.

The drafts also found no evidence that the program was partial to critics of the redevelopment, despite acknowledging that a reasonable viewer might regard it as critical of how the project was conducted. Internal material described the reporting as containing sufficient diversity of perspectives, probing questions and fair-minded treatment of the issues. ABC Media Watch said the later change required staff to retrofit a breach finding into material that had initially reached the opposite conclusion.

ACMA’s Authority ultimately found that the program breached the ABC Code of Practice 2024. ACMA said the episode did not adequately explain that three supporting findings in the audit were assessed as “largely effective, ” omitted that the memorial had accepted all five audit recommendations, and blurred two stages of the consultation process.

The regulator also found that the program’s treatment of the audit, interview selection and presentation of contentious issues lacked sufficient context, while rejecting a separate accuracy complaint concerning Last Post audio and construction footage. ACMA said the ABC disputed the impartiality finding and did not plan remedial action; it may recommend action but cannot compel the broadcaster to take it.

The ABC’s written response called the finding unprecedented and unworkable, said the program had been reviewed internally by news, legal and editorial-policy teams, and argued that the decision could chill investigative journalism or impose false balance. ACMA said the documents reflected normal collective decision-making and that significant investigations are ultimately decided by the Authority after considering the complaint, the ABC’s submissions and staff analysis. The dispute leaves the regulator’s handling of the investigation, and the meaning of impartiality for public-interest reporting, under renewed scrutiny.

Read the full account of the story

More from the News desk

More from News · Back to Polaris Insights