THE DAY, IN CONTEXTPolaris InsightsAn AI-powered comprehensive news portal

POLARIS INSIGHTS

VGT’s decade-long lead over VUG comes with greater concentration and risk

VGT’s decade-long lead over VUG comes with greater concentration and risk

Two Vanguard exchange-traded funds offer investors different ways to pursue growth. Vanguard Morningstar Growth ETF, known by its ticker VUG, tracks the Morningstar U.S. Vanguard Information Technology ETF, or VGT, tracks an information-technology index spanning U.S.

Nvidia, Apple, and Microsoft are leading holdings in both funds, but VGT assigns more weight to those companies, particularly Nvidia. The supplied comparison put Nvidia at 17.6% of VGT and 13.5% of VUG, while the three largest VGT positions together represented about 45% of assets.

VUG had the cost advantage. Vanguard listed its expense ratio at 0.03%, compared with 0.09% for VGT. Vanguard’s fund pages also describe VUG as a passively managed portfolio designed to replicate its large-cap growth benchmark, while VGT is built to track a benchmark for information-technology stocks. The difference in fees is modest in dollar terms, but it compounds over long holding periods and makes VUG the cheaper option before performance is considered.

Historical results favored VGT by a wide margin in the supplied comparison. A trailing 10-year total return of 775% for VGT compared with 420% for VUG would have turned a hypothetical $10,000 investment into nearly $88,000 in VGT over the period cited. Both funds benefited from the technology and artificial-intelligence surge, while Nvidia’s reported 12,910% gain over the same decade helped explain why the more concentrated fund pulled ahead.

That record does not establish which fund will lead next. For investors with long horizons and a higher tolerance for volatility, the comparison favors VGT as the more aggressive choice; investors seeking lower fees and broader diversification may prefer VUG.

Read the full account of the story

More from the AI desk

More from AI · Back to Polaris Insights